The Eccles Institute and BAAS’s America Now! series continues on Tuesday 25 March 2025, with ‘True Crime in the USA’. Ahead of the event, here’s a look at the speakers joining us for the evening, and some materials related to true crime in the British Library’s collections.
"True crime" is a very American genre, and a very American obsession. Evolving from the yellow journalism of press barons like Hearst and Pulitzer, and new forms of literature like Truman Capote's In Cold Blood, true crime has also been central to the rise of new media and technology content creation and consumption over the past decade. Podcasting, streaming, and social media would not be what they are today without the American public's fascination with narrativizing violence, deception, and intrigue involving their fellow citizens. This panel of experts is on the case and will trace the threads that connect everything from Billy the Kid to Luigi Mangione, and from Serial and Making a Murderer to TikTok detectives and the very online, real-time, true crime-style storytelling of the present moment.
Promotional image for America Now True Crime event, Tuesday 25 March 2025
Chaired by our friends at BAAS, the event will include a panel of experts to lead what’s sure to be an engaging and enlightening discussion:
Dr George Larke-Walsh (University of Sunderland)
George is currently Senior Lecturer in Arts and Creative Industries at the University of Sunderland. She began her academic career in the north east, but then moved to the USA, teaching at the University of North Texas from 2004 to 2020. She has published books and articles on mythologies of the mafia on screen, including the Wiley-Blackwell Companion to the Gangster Film (2018) [when the British Library’s digital services are fully restored this item is available to consult at BL shelfmark ELD.DS.326648]*. More recently she has turned her attention to documentary and specifically true crime. Her articles have explored numerous media examples from histories of the mafia wars to well-known series such as Making a Murderer, and The Staircase. Her most recent book is an edited collection of new scholarship called True Crime in American Media (Routledge, 2023).
Megan Lupton (De Montfort University)
Megan is a final year PhD candidate at De Montfort University in Leicester. To investigate the ethics of true crime, she has conducted interviews with true crime podcasters and is using her findings to inform the characters, plot and themes in a fictional novel. Megan has previously spoken about child safety on TikTok at the TikTok Cultures Research Network symposium, presented at the 2024 Great Writing Conference, and written for the National Centre of Academic Excellence. She is also the co-founder of an independent, cooperative newspaper in Leicestershire, and a passionate storyteller with a master's degree in creative writing. Through her solutions-focused PhD, Megan’s novel and ethical reflections framework will take true crime practitioners on a journey through ethics.
Her Instagram account, documents her research journey.
Dr Lindsay Steenberg (Oxford Brookes University)
Lindsay is Reader/Associate Professor in Film Studies at Oxford Brookes University where she is Chair of their Equality, Diversity and Inclusion Research Network. She has published numerous articles on the crime and action genres and is the author of Forensic Science in Contemporary American Popular Culture: Gender, Crime, and Science (2017) [BL shelfmark: YK.2013.a.8439], Are You Not Entertained? Mapping the Gladiator in Visual Culture (2021) [BL shelfmark: YC.2022.a.14] and the forthcoming The Hollywood Fight Scene. She is particularly interested in the gender and race politics of violence in the popular media, from the lighter mode of ‘cozy crime’ to the darker obsessions of ‘dark tourism.’
The British Library collections hold a host of materials reflecting the American true crime genre and conversation. Secondary sources include true stories of domestic terrorism [BL shelfmark: m22/.10005] to anthologies offering comprehensive examinations of how American writers have explored crime in a multitude of ways, from Nathaniel Hawthorne to James Ellroy [BL shelfmark: m08/.33001]. True crime events which have proven ongoing subjects of fascination and discussion, such as the bloody St. Valentine's Day massacre of 1929, can be examined through online access to FBI documents* and music scores from the 1967 film of the same name [BL shelfmark: VOC/1967/NEWMAN]. If you really want to investigate early depictions of sensationalised crime, look at A Short Narrative of the Horrid Massacre in Boston perpetrated in the evening of the fifth day of March 1770 by soldiers of the XXIXth Regiment [BL shelfmark: 1061.h.11.] which includes Paul Revere’s engraving of the event we know now as the Boston Massacre, a pivotal event leading up to the American Revolution.
Image of Paul Revere engraving from A Short Narrative of the Horrid Massacre in Boston perpetrated in the evening of the fifth day of March 1770 by soldiers of the XXIXth Regiment ... with some observations on the state of things prior to that catastrophe., Boston, 1770, 1061.h.11.
For those interested in early sensationalised journalism, 1883 examples of the The New-York World can be viewed on microfilm at BL shelfmark: MFM.MA79. The New-York World was established in 1860 but by the late 1870s the newspaper was losing money, tens of thousands of dollars a year. In 1883 it was purchased by Joseph Pulitzer who turned around its precarious fate. Hiring investigative journalists, it became a newspaper that concentrated on human-interest stories, scandal and exaggerated material, capturing readers' attention and upping its daily circulation. In response, William Randolph Hearst purchased the New York Journal in 1895 and employed an approach like Pulitzer. Pulitzer and Heart’s use of promotional schemes, overemphasised stories, and focus on illustrations and colour supplements, became known as yellow journalism and would have a lasting impact on the history of popular American newspaper production.
Image from Joseph Pulitzer and the New York World. [With plates, including portraits.], BL shelfmark: X.900/2277, Princeton, 1966. The image shows one the newspaper’s front pages: a depiction of James Blaine’s attendance at a banquet in New York City, tendered by the nation’s foremost millionaires.
On our whistlestop tour of true crime through the 19th to 21st centuries in British Library collections, you may also be interested to find Pat F. Garrett's Authentic Life of Billy the Kid (William H. Bonney) [BL shelfmark: 010884.f.37.]. Originally published one year after the killing of Billy the Kid by Sheriff Pat Garrett, Sheriff of Lincoln County, New Mexico, this is considered one of the most authoritative biographies of William H. Bonney and the foundation of the Billy the Kid legend.
Image from Pat F. Garrett's Authentic Life of Billy the Kid (William H. Bonney) [BL shelfmark: 010884.f.37.] with colour depiction of Billy the Kid by W. M. Allison
Truman Capote is often a name that springs to mind on the subject of true crime. His 1966 novel, In Cold Blood, reconstructs the real-life murder in 1959 of a Kansas farmer, his wife and both their children, combining factual reporting with the imaginary possibilities of storytelling. The book is deemed by many to represent a milestone in the evolution of American true crime writing with Capote himself promoting the book as a new genre: the ‘literary non-fiction' novel. First published serially, in The New Yorker in 1965, Readers at the British Library can consult a first edition of the novel, published by Random House, New York, in the same year, at BL shelfmark: W13/2998 and later British-published edition from 1966 at BL shelfmark: 12208.a.1/2682.
Images of front and back covers of paper back Penguin Books edition of In Cold Blood, 1966 [BL shelfmark: 12208.a.1/2682.]
We move swiftly into the era of podcasts and giant streaming services. The story of a 1999 murder case in Baltimore was reinvestigated in 2014 by Serial, an investigative journalism podcast, in which host Sarah Koenig narrated the nonfiction story over multiple episodes. The show became a cultural phenomenon, launching podcasts into the mainstream. The experience of the young man examined in relation to the murder, Adnan Syed, can be explored further in collection item Adnan's story: the search for truth and justice after Serial [BL shelfmark: YD.2017.a.627]. And finally, with the likes of Netflix tapping into the true crime trend, tough, sometimes controversial, and often needs-to-be-seen-to-be-believed watching has been provided through shows like Tiger King (2020), Monsters (2024) and Apple Cider Vinegar (2025) all of which can be examined in BL items ELD.DS.732936,* YK.1994.a.14823, and YKL.2018.a.20024 respectively.
Photo from Adnan's story: the search for truth and justice after Serial [BL shelfmark: YD.2017.a.627] including notes from Baltimore Police Department detailing the discovery of a female body.
From the Supreme Court to Cowboy Carter, you can catch up on the other topics we’ve covered in America Now! via our blog series:
If you’ve attended one of our America Now! events or have ideas about what you think we should discuss in the series, we’d love to hear from you. Share your thoughts and feedback via our online form.
*Access to some digital items and e-resources is currently limited while we recover from the cyber-attack of 2023. We are working to reinstate these and hope to provide full access again when possible. Visit our website for full details of what is currently accessible.