Stories from Provenance Research: Records and Manuscripts Lost at Sea (Part 1): SS Oceana
The India Office often borrowed documents from India for administrative purposes and frequently sent out manuscripts from its Library to scholars across the world for academic research. Until the middle of the 20th century, there was little alternative to transporting documents by ship. As we shall see from this and a subsequent post, 1912 was a particularly bad year for both the Government of Bombay and the India Office for losing records and manuscripts at sea.
Wreck of the Oceana from Illustrated London News 23 March 1912 Image © Illustrated London News Group, created courtesy of The British Library Board - British Newspaper Archive
On 16 March 1912, the SS Oceana was wrecked off Beachy Head on the Sussex coast after a collision with the Pisagua. Tragically, seventeen people lost their lives when a lifeboat capsized. The Oceana was heading for India on the run from Tilbury to Bombay and on board was the Surat Factory Inwards Letterbook, 1646-47, which was being returned to the Government of Bombay. Part of a series of records charting the earliest years of the East India Company in Surat, it had been sent to London in November 1911 at the behest of Registrar William Foster. Foster was working on a series of calendars of early records, published as The English Factories in India (1911 onwards).
It was the Surat volume’s second trip to London, having been previously sent by the Government of Bombay for conservation work due to its fragile state. The volume was conserved and rebound at the Public Records Office in Chancery Lane in 1901-02 with eleven other volumes of ‘ancient records’ from Bombay. The conservation work cost the Government of Bombay £74 10 shillings, above the original estimate of £68. Before the volumes were finally returned to India in 1905, copies of anything not in the collection in London were made, primarily by Miss Ethel Bruce Sainsbury, who was employed by the Record Department for her archival and palaeographical skills. For the publication though, Foster was keen to check the original against the copy, and requested the volume be borrowed again. It is perhaps ironic that the conserved state of the volume made the loan less of a concern.
The shipping and loss of the Surat Letter Book - IOR/L/R/6/333 (R1910/12)
Foster reported the loss to Bombay on 5 July 1912. He had hoped that as he had requested special care should be taken of the Surat volume, P&O - the owners of the Oceana – might have placed it in the ship’s safe, which was subsequently salvaged along with the ship’s cargo of gold and silver ingots. When the safe was opened however, the Surat volume was not to be found. All Foster could do was to send a typed copy of the transcript to Bombay as recompense. Meanwhile, Foster’s annotated copy of the Surat Inwards Letter Book 1646-1647 survives in the India Office Records as IOR/G/36/102A.
Surat Letter Book 1646-1647 first page of typescript IOR/G/36/102A
Lesley Shapland
Archivist & Provenance Researcher
India Office Records
Further reading:
Details regarding the conservation, copying and return of Surat Letter Book and other volumes from Bombay can be found in IOR/L/R/6/220 (R923/01), IOR/L/R/6/224 (R1566/01), IOR/L/R/6/231 (R1122/02), and IOR/L/R/6/265 (R440/05).
Details regarding Foster’s loan of the Surat Letter Book and its subsequent loss can be found in IOR/L/R/6/333 (R1910/12).
Ethel Bruce Sainsbury, daughter of Assistant Keeper of the Public Records William Noel Sainsbury, was employed by the India Office Record Department from 1899. Her contribution to the work of the Department, including transcription, calendaring and publication can be traced through William Foster’s Departmental Annual Reports in the series IOR/L/R/6 & IOR/L/R/7.